DataBrighten

    Pupils below minimum reading proficiency at end of primary (%). Low GAML threshold

    317 × 6rows × columns: 125 countries, 2001 to 2023

    Real data: World Bank, World Development Indicators, indicator SE.LPV.PRIM.LD, retrieved 19 November 2026. Values are as published; we only reshaped the file.

    textnumberdateyes/no
    Rows317country-year values
    Countries125with at least one value
    Years2001 – 202317 years with data
    LicenceCC BY 4.0credit the World Bank

    What it measures

    The share of pupils at the end of primary schooling who are below the minimum proficiency level (MPL) for reading or learning deprived. The MPL in reading at the end of primary is defined by the Global Alliance to Monitor Learning (GAML), measured in standard learning assessments, and reported in the context of the SDG 4.1.1b monitoring. It is “Students independently and fluently read simple, short narrative and expository texts. They locate explicitly-stated information. They interpret and give some explanations about the key ideas in these texts. They provide simple, personal opinions or…

    Read the full definition

    The share of pupils at the end of primary schooling who are below the minimum proficiency level (MPL) for reading or learning deprived. The MPL in reading at the end of primary is defined by the Global Alliance to Monitor Learning (GAML), measured in standard learning assessments, and reported in the context of the SDG 4.1.1b monitoring. It is “Students independently and fluently read simple, short narrative and expository texts. They locate explicitly-stated information. They interpret and give some explanations about the key ideas in these texts. They provide simple, personal opinions or judgements about the information, events and characters in a text.” (UIS and GAML 2019). In other words, a child “attaining” minimum proficiency has the ability to read and understand a short passage of age-appropriate material, whether a simple story or non-fiction narrative of a few paragraphs. In addition to this nutshell statement, the GAML has also proposed a common terminology to describe classifications in the context of the MPL. This is a critical first step toward linking cross-national and national learning assessments with a common benchmark.

    Limits and exceptions (World Bank note)

    The process of equating proficiency levels on different assessments to the GAML definition is not straightforward. Even the long-running regional assessment initiatives like PASEC (West and Central Africa) and LLECE (Latin America and the Caribbean) use different definitions and a different number of levels than other assessments like PIRLS, and those might not even be the same over time. Their test development methodologies and test administration procedures also vary. Moreover, because not all countries participate in global or regional assessments, for some major countries we rely on their interim reporting using their national assessments; equating these assessments is even more challenging. UIS and the World Bank have mapped how proficiency levels between assessment can equate to one another, but they are not strictly comparable. Among the differences across assessments, one important point concerns the age at which children are tested. The reference age for our exercise is age 10. However, all learning assessments used in this analysis are sampled based on specific grades rather than age. PIRLS and TIMSS are administered in Grade 4, meaning that the average student assessed

    The numbers in 2021

    In 2021, 53 countries have a value. The highest is South Africa (80.55); the lowest is Russian Federation (1.64). The median country value is 6.41. The World Bank's World aggregate for 2019 is 49.59.

    Top 10 countries, 2021

    value

    Source: World Bank, SE.LPV.PRIM.LD, retrieved 19 November 2026. Computed from pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv.

    Highest, 2021

    #CountryValue
    1South Africa80.55
    2Morocco59.42
    3Egypt, Arab Rep.55.43
    4Jordan53.36
    5Iran, Islamic Rep.41.4
    6Kosovo37.92
    7Oman37.8
    8Azerbaijan32.57
    9Uzbekistan30.16
    10North Macedonia30.04

    Lowest, 2021

    #CountryValue
    1Russian Federation1.64
    2Hong Kong SAR, China1.72
    3Croatia1.92
    4Ireland2.22
    5Poland2.79
    6Italy2.82
    7Lithuania2.89
    8United Kingdom2.98
    9Singapore3.34
    10Finland3.52
    How many countries report, by decade
    DecadeMost countries in one year
    2000s49
    2010s47
    2020s53

    World aggregate by year

    As published by the World Bank (in the regions file, not the country file).

    YearWorld
    201949.59
    201545.9

    First rows

    pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv

    countrytextiso3textregiontextincome_grouptextyearnumbervaluenumber
    AfghanistanAFGMiddle East, North Africa, Afghanistan & PakistanLow income201388
    AlbaniaALBEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income20217.8805923461914
    AlgeriaDZAMiddle East, North Africa, Afghanistan & PakistanUpper middle income200766.5280303955078
    ArgentinaARGLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income200655.2967185974121
    ArgentinaARGLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income201353.5789604187011
    ArgentinaARGLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income201958.9338607788085
    ArmeniaARMEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income200334.457950592041
    ArmeniaARMEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income200723.4219932556152

    Data dictionary

    ColumnTypeMeaning
    countrytextCountry or economy, World Bank name
    iso3textISO 3166-1 alpha-3 code
    regiontextWorld Bank region
    income_grouptextWorld Bank income group
    yearnumberCalendar year of the value
    valuenumberPupils below minimum reading proficiency at end of primary (%). Low GAML threshold, exactly as the World Bank API returns it (not rounded)

    Only country-years with a value are in the long file; blank cells in the wide file mean no value was published.

    Practice questions

    answers computed from the file

    Which country has the highest value in 2021?

    South Africa, with 80.55.

    Excel (on the long CSV: E = year, F = value)

    =FILTER(A2:A100000,(E2:E100000=2021)*(F2:F100000=MAXIFS(F2:F100000,E2:E100000,2021)))

    SQL (table wb = the CSV)

    SELECT country, value FROM wb WHERE year = 2021
      AND value = (SELECT MAX(value) FROM wb WHERE year = 2021);

    pandas (df = pd.read_csv("pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv"))

    y = df[df.year == 2021]
    y[y.value == y.value.max()][["country", "value"]]

    File: pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv

    How many countries report a value for 2021?

    53 of the 217 economies in the file's country list.

    Excel (on the long CSV: E = year, F = value)

    =COUNTIF(E2:E100000,2021)

    SQL (table wb = the CSV)

    SELECT COUNT(*) FROM wb WHERE year = 2021;

    pandas (df = pd.read_csv("pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv"))

    (df.year == 2021).sum()

    File: pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv

    What is the median across countries in 2021?

    6.41 (median of the 53 country values; not a World Bank aggregate).

    Excel (on the long CSV: E = year, F = value)

    =MEDIAN(FILTER(F2:F100000,E2:E100000=2021))

    SQL (table wb = the CSV)

    -- SQLite has no MEDIAN(); this picks the middle value(s)
    SELECT AVG(value) FROM (SELECT value FROM wb WHERE year = 2021 ORDER BY value
      LIMIT 2 - (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM wb WHERE year = 2021) % 2
      OFFSET (SELECT (COUNT(*) - 1) / 2 FROM wb WHERE year = 2021));

    pandas (df = pd.read_csv("pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv"))

    df[df.year == 2021]["value"].median()

    File: pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv

    Which country rose the most between 2011 and 2021?

    Iran, Islamic Rep.: from 24.26 to 41.4, a rise of 17.15 (out of 36 countries with both years).

    Excel (on the long CSV: E = year, F = value)

    Use the wide file (pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold-wide.csv): add a column = [2021] - [2011], then sort it largest to smallest.

    SQL (table wb = the CSV)

    SELECT a.country, b.value - a.value AS rise FROM wb a JOIN wb b ON a.iso3 = b.iso3
    WHERE a.year = 2011 AND b.year = 2021 ORDER BY rise DESC LIMIT 1;

    pandas (df = pd.read_csv("pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv"))

    w = df.pivot(index="country", columns="year", values="value")
    (w[2021] - w[2011]).dropna().nlargest(1)

    File: pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv

    Which year has the most countries reporting?

    2021, with 53 countries. (Later years are still filling in as countries report.)

    Excel (on the long CSV: E = year, F = value)

    Make a pivot table: year in Rows, Count of value in Values, then sort by the count.

    SQL (table wb = the CSV)

    SELECT year, COUNT(*) AS n FROM wb GROUP BY year ORDER BY n DESC, year DESC LIMIT 1;

    pandas (df = pd.read_csv("pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv"))

    df.groupby("year").size().sort_values(ascending=False).head(1)

    File: pupils-below-minimum-reading-proficiency-at-end-of-primary-percent-low-gaml-threshold.csv